What independent reviews say: where they agree and where they don't
Three full French reviews have been available since late March 2026. They agree on the essentials but split on one concrete point, and we'd rather flag it than smooth it over.
Runninglab (Julien Guyod, overall score 8.8/10) delivers the most critical and most data-driven review of the three. Detailed subscores: comfort 9.5/10, responsiveness 8/10, foot hold 9/10, stability 9/10, lifespan 9/10, value for money 8/10, design 9/10. The tester puts a precise number on the weight problem: 286 g versus 244 g for a New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v15, a 42 g gap you feel at the end of a long run. He also argues that the Helion foam, an EVA/OBC compound, isn't the most advanced on the market next to the PEBA or A-TPU formulas now common among competitors at the same price, and he finds the price high for that technology. Estimated lifespan: around 600 km with no premature wear.
Runpack (Simon Raffi) confirms the positive trend with similar subscores: comfort 9/10, responsiveness 8/10, cushioning 9/10, stability and hold 8/10, grip 9/10, tested on dry and wet surfaces. The tester places its sweet spot between 3:30 and 3:40 per kilometer for an experienced runner, and closer to 3:50 to 4:00 for a regular runner, which confirms its role as a daily trainer rather than a fast tempo shoe. One key point he raised on his own: expect a 70 to 80 km break-in before the foam fully softens, a detail missing from the other reviews.
Jolie Foulée (Lionel Fracture) is the most qualitative of the three, and very positive about the new silhouette: "slimmer and sleeker" than version 2, a redesigned heel with a small point that improves hold, and a mesh that looks durable in use. On fit, though, this review directly contradicts the other two. Where Runninglab and Runpack describe a fit that's back to normal (no more sizing down as with the V2), Jolie Foulée explicitly recommends going up half a size. We found no obvious explanation for the gap (the tester's foot shape, a different colorway tested) and would rather flag it than force a verdict: try the shoe on before buying online if you're unsure about your usual On size.
One last point: English-language lab measurements, which we consulted for reference, point the same way. The foam feels noticeably firmer out of the box than on the Cloudmonster 2, which matches Runpack's observation about the break-in period.

© On, official photo used for editorial purposes